Mayville Homes under $500,000

Mayville Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Mayville, Michigan—a charming village that perfectly blends small-town warmth with the beauty of the great outdoors. Nestled in the heart of Tuscola County, Mayville is known for its friendly community, scenic landscapes, and rich history. With a population of just over 1,000 residents, this quaint locale offers a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a close-knit community.

Mayville's picturesque surroundings are perfect for nature enthusiasts. Explore the nearby parks, enjoy fishing in the local rivers, or take a leisurely stroll along the walking trails that wind through the lush greenery. The village is also home to a variety of local shops, cafes, and restaurants, ensuring that residents have everything they need within easy reach.

One of the most appealing aspects of Mayville is the availability of homes under $500,000. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, looking to upgrade, or seeking a cozy retirement haven, Mayville has a diverse range of properties to suit your needs. From charming bungalows and spacious family homes to modern new builds, there’s something for everyone. With affordable housing options, you can enjoy the benefits of homeownership without breaking the bank.

In Mayville, you’ll find not just a house, but a place to truly call home. Experience the warmth of community living, the serenity of nature, and the joy of finding your perfect property—all in one delightful village. Discover Mayville today, and let your new adventure begin!

Newest Mayville Homes under $500,000

725 W Saginaw Road, Mayville
$300,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61038083 MLS
Discover the possibilities with this 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering approximately 1,700 square feet of living space on 5 acres in Mayville! The property features a spacious 42' x 50' pole barn, providing abundant room for storage, equipment, hobbies, or workshop space. Inside, the ranch-style layout offers convenient single-level living with three bedrooms and two full bathrooms. Major property features include an on-demand hot water system approximately 5 years old, a generator approximately 8 years old, and a roof approximately 10 years old. A transferable warranty is also included, offering added value for the next owner, subject to the warranty's terms and conditions. Enjoy the added space and versatility that come with acreage while remaining close to the amenities of Mayville. Local conveniences include Neiman's Family Market, downtown dining, Mayville Roadside Park, and access to M-24 for travel throughout the surrounding area. Whether you're looking for extra room for projects, storage, or outdoor pursuits, this property offers a unique combination of ranch-style living, acreage, and substantial outbuilding space. Don't miss the opportunity to explore everything this Mayville property has to offer!

725 W Saginaw Road, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of @properties Christie's Int'l R.E. Birmingham, Office Phone: 248-850-8632
6130 3rd Street, Mayville
$224,995
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 61037209 MLS
No trick with this newly update home it's just a sweet treat of a deal. New kitchen cabinets and countertop. Fresh paint through the entire house. New carpet and laminate flooring has been installed so all rooms have clean spotless coverings. New Exterior doors That are keyed alike so no sorting for the right key to any door. Bathroom has been completely redone with dual flush toilets, cabinets,sink,and tub, It's spic and span and ready to go! New slider door from dining area out to the spacious backyard. Two car garage only minimal steps from the house to the back door. New remote Double garage door just installed for Ease of excess in the winter weather coming soon. Exterior has fresh paint and attractive landscaping add to give that great curb appeal. Nothing more to do but move in immediately! Owner has spared no expenses on updating the house from one end to the other. New carpet and laminate flooring, all fresh paint in every room. New kitchen cabinets, bathroom is brand spanking new from top to bottom, new exterior doors including a slider out to the backyard. Full dry basement for storage or added living space if you are into doing a project. 2 car garage has remote door for ease of coming or going when the snow begins to fly. House sits on 1 and 1/2 spacious lots.

6130 3rd Street, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Sunshine Real Estate Co, Office Phone: 989-550-8028
6056 Lincoln Street, Mayville
$119,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61033902 MLS
This two-story home offers four bedrooms, main floor bathroom, and laundry room. The rooms are nice in size. The kitchen is spacious and full of cupboards. The kitchen, dining and living room floor plan flows nicely together but still gives it a separate feel. There is one bedroom on the main floor. Three bedrooms on the second level with a landing area that could make great space for the kids to play. This home has a Michigan walkout basement suitable place to store the lawn mower and more. The home is close to town and within walking distance of the school and stores. The roof is newer in 2023. It has so much potential, it needs some TLC. Come check it out and put your own personal touches into it and make it your own.

6056 Lincoln Street, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Motivated Real Estate, Office Phone: 810-834-5404
6035 Lincoln Street, Mayville
$150,000
ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 61031605 MLS
TURNKEY RANCH IN DOWNTOWN MAYVILLE! This meticulously MAINTAINED 3 bedroom / 1 bath home is ready to MOVE RIGHT INTO! Spacious primary bedroom. UPDATED BATHROOM. First Floor Laundry. GAME ROOM complete with custom, wood-crafted BAR. FINISHED SHED offers plenty of room for storage and WORKSPACE. Newer windows, roof, furnace and A/C. KEYS AT CLOSING!

6035 Lincoln Street, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of eXp Realty Best Life and Company, Office Phone: 248-629-0791
3540 Lee Hill Road, Mayville
$224,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61030399 MLS
Great opportunity on this 5 bedroom home on over 2 acres with a 3+ car garage and additional pole barn. This home has a lot of living space. Separate living room and huge family room. Plus there is an additional flex room on the second floor. There are 3 bedrooms on the main floor and 2 additional upstairs. Newer metal roof on the home. Newer composite front porch and back deck. The attached garage is 3 cars wide and extra deep. Then there is an additional pole barn with 3 garage doors and a second floor storage or workshop. Immediate occupancy is available.

3540 Lee Hill Road, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Realty Executives Main St LLC, Office Phone: 810-667-1700
1313 E Murphy Lake Road, Mayville
$249,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61030093 MLS
It's all been updated in the last 6 months. New steel roof, new steel siding, new windows and door wall. Beautiful kitchen with granite countertops, all new appliances and a snack bar so everyone can hang. New flooring and new bathrooms with all new tubs, vanities and stools. This house has Affadavit of Affixture and is ready to go! Well has been chlorinated and vapor barrier under the home has been updated. Nice and dry. Deck is freshly stained and leads to a 2 car detached garage. Fish are jumping in the pond and this all sits on 4.7 acres of country living!

1313 E Murphy Lake Road, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Coulter Real Estate, Office Phone: 810-346-4206
6245 Fulton Street, Mayville
$220,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61029859 MLS
There is something special about a home that has a story to tell! Set on a spacious double corner lot surrounded by mature trees, this 4-bedroom, 2-bath Colonial in Mayville blends historic character with the space and functionality that make a home comfortable for everyday living. From the decorative colonial trim and crown molding to the hardwood floors and vintage details, this home offers timeless character throughout. The heart of the home is the large, open kitchen, dining, and great room--an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. The great room features a brick fireplace, while the kitchen offers a center island and recessed wall oven. First-floor laundry adds everyday convenience, and the bedrooms feature comfortable carpeting. The office could be turned into a fifth bedroom! Outside, the property offers even more space and versatility. The two-car garage provides direct access to the basement for convenient storage. A standout feature is the impressive two-story vintage carriage house with its own electrical subpanel--offering excellent potential for a workshop, studio, hobby space, additional storage, or other future possibilities. One of the everyday conveniences of this property is its location just a short walk to the local schools and park. Whether heading to school, attending a sporting event, catching a game, or participating in other school and community activities, having the schools nearby makes it easy to stay connected to what's happening in town. Additional improvements include newer roof and windows. Sewer line replaced in 2024. Soffits, facia and gutters updated 2026. New AC 2022 and water heater 2024. With its double corner lot, mature trees, spacious living areas, distinctive Colonial architecture, and rare two-story carriage house, this Mayville property offers a wonderful combination of historic charm, functionality, and room to make it your own. B.A.T.V.A.I

6245 Fulton Street, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Brookstone, Realtors LLC, Office Phone: 248-963-0501
4621 Hurds Corner Road, Mayville
$299,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 50221440 MLS
LOOKING FOR MORE THAN JUST A HOUSE? This beautiful 2.28-acre country property offers the space, versatility and outbuildings that are increasingly hard to find—all in one incredible package! Imagine mornings overlooking your peaceful pond as wildlife wanders through, evenings relaxing on the revitalized back deck, and finally having room for the animals, hobbies, equipment and lifestyle you’ve been dreaming about. Inside, 2,187 sq. ft. offers plenty of room to spread out with an 18x11 living room, 18x11 family room and exceptional flexibility. The former garage has been transformed into approximately 22x17 of additional living space with a lavatory and 15x7 wet bar area. Additional rooms offer even more possibilities—extra bedrooms, home office, hobby space or potential extended-family living. Outside, a 32x24 horse barn, 12x20 shed and impressive 30x40 INSULATED AND HEATED pole building. There is a 50x16 enclosed garden with 10 ft walls. A full, dry basement, water softener, reverse-osmosis system and professional weatherization add even more value. Come explore the possibilities and see just how much this property has to offer!

4621 Hurds Corner Road, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of DeMark Real Estate, Office Phone:

2732 Obrien Road, Mayville
$499,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61027161 MLS
Head to the back 40--because you finally can. Set on a square 40 pristine, wooded acres with maintained paths winding through the property with multiple raised hunting blinds, this unique raised ranch offers the rare combination of acreage, privacy, functional outbuildings and thoughtful updates- just minutes from M-46, M-24 and M-15 for an easy commute. The 20x24' outbuilding is a blank canvas with serious potential, featuring a cement floor, storage underneath, electricity and its own second driveway. Create a workshop, studio, additional hangout space, hobby building or future finished space. Nearly 1,600 square feet of living space was completely remodeled in 2013, creating a home that feels perfectly suited to its wooded surroundings. The open dining and living rooms center around a wood-burning fireplace and flow into the one-of-a-kind kitchen with vaulted ceilings, rich wood cabinetry, walk-in pantry, butcher block island, and access to the back deck, where mature woods make you feel completely removed from it all. A knotty pine accent ceiling leads toward three bedrooms, including a primary retreat with its own four-season porch and access to updated full bath with tiled shower and deep, jetted tub. The finished lower level adds flexibility with garage access, a second full bathroom with walk-in shower, family room with electric fireplace and abundant storage. Major updates include electrical panel (2013), furnace and AC by SIR (2020), water heater (2026), water softener, vinyl/Pella windows and generator outlet. High-speed internet is available through Thumb Electric. Outside, the acreage offers room to roam and abundant hunting opportunities with maintained paths, wildlife pond, fruit trees, hardwoods, garden area and an RV carport. Whether you're exploring the woods, working on a project, watching wildlife from the deck or simply enjoying the privacy, this is country living with space that's increasingly difficult to find.

2732 Obrien Road, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Knockout Real Estate, Office Phone: 989-652-6300
1660 W Brown Road, Mayville
$315,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 61024234 MLS
A rare opportunity to own a Centennial Farm where history, country charm, and modern updates come together in a truly special setting. The property enjoys peaceful views of neighboring apple orchards and wide-open fields, creating a beautiful country backdrop with abundant wildlife. The 2.6-acre farm itself features plentiful pear trees and thoughtfully maintained landscaping. Much of the home was built or extensively remodeled in 2007, blending updated living spaces with original farmhouse character. A recently installed whole-home generator provides added peace of mind for country living. The spacious primary suite features a large en-suite bathroom and walk-in closet, while the second main-floor bedroom is also generously sized. The enclosed front room is an ideal spot for a cozy hangout, sunroom, or plant-filled retreat to enjoy morning coffee and peaceful country views. Several areas--including the upstairs, living room, and an additional room that would make a beautiful library or sitting room--have not yet been renovated and are ready for someone with creativity and vision to make their own. The original farmhouse rests on a traditional Michigan stone basement, while the newer addition features a tall block basement with an extra-wide staircase for easier access. Outside, the property offers an impressive collection of outbuildings. In addition to the 2-car detached garage, you'll find a large pole barn, milk shed, and chicken coop with concrete floors and electricity. A separate barn near the edge of the property has dirt floors and provides additional space for equipment, recreational toys, animals, or storage. With historic roots, mature pear trees, multiple outbuildings, a whole-home generator, peaceful surroundings, abundant wildlife, and opportunities to put your own stamp on the original spaces, this Centennial Farm offers the chance to become the next steward of a special piece of Michigan history.

1660 W Brown Road, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Sunshine Real Estate Co, Office Phone: 989-550-8028
6032 Fox Street, Mayville
$99,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 50216485 MLS
A true Diamond in the rough with endless potential. This home features an updated kitchen while offering the perfect opportunity to add your own personal touches. Comfortable enough to move right in and make improvements over time. It's an ideal chance to build value through updates. Whether you're a first-time home buyer or someone looking to create their forever home, this property is full of possibilities. Don't miss the opportunity to make it your own.

6032 Fox Street, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Realty Executives Home Towne Romeo, Office Phone: 586-786-4617
6029 Fulton Street, Mayville
$199,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 50215856 MLS
Wait! What? How many kitchens? Let me explain! Although this property is zoned commercial, it houses 3 residential apartments plus a storefront! The owner has lived in the upstairs unit for decades and taxes ae 33% homestaded. This updated, well maintained historical building in the heart of Mayville Village is beautiful, charming, functional and loaded with quick possibilities! The chic modern facade was updated 2 years ago & immediately catches the eye. Ornate Original Brickwork has been routinely serviced & well preserved. An impressive multi story deck addition allows apartments their own outdoor terrace for summer enjoyment & easy access to private parking in back. Other major building updates inc: Roof 2016*Boiler 2018*Windows*Electrical*Egress window for lower apt 2025. Upper apartment is on its own meter. Street and lower level areas combined on 2nd meter. The upper floor 3 bed apartment is a mix of w/ old world charm & modern functionality. Soaring 10+' ceilings, Original 8" oak floorboards & window trim, quaint built-ins, updated (2024) country kitchen w/wood ceiling & artisan wood floor showcasing 17 types of wood! Huge storage area w/beautiful built in oak cupboard/shelving. Full bath updated 2024 & comfy sunroom off deck. Floorplan might allow for this to be converted to 2 units. The street level offers a storefront currently being used for a beauty salon. Front Display window, multiple plumbing hookups, small kitchenette & Storage area. The back apartment can be accessed from the street level or through the terrace in back. Good sized livingroom & bedroom. Kitchen w/access to terrace. Full bath incl laundry hookup. Basement apartment features full kitchen, livingroom, office, large bedroom w/new 20x24 window, full bath & covered patio area. Large workshop/mechanical room for tinkering and storage

6029 Fulton Street, Mayville

Listing Courtesy of Red Carpet Keim Action Group 1, Office Phone: 810-653-0600
Start Your Search